Alex "Axel" Smith weigh-in (LH)

[Axel]

[Axel]

So I forgot to create a poll, and now I can't figure out how to add one to the post. The internet is fun.

[amadarwin]

Not sure you can once you post it. I went ahead and made it for you. I like the lines, chose a solid heavy.

[Juggertha]

Great stuff, Axel. That last panel's smirk got me.

[Axel]

Not sure you can once you post it. I went ahead and made it for you. I like the lines, chose a solid heavy.

thanks on both counts!

[Axel]

Great stuff, Axel. That last panel's smirk got me.

Mission accomplished.

[Popninja]

Based solely on these three images, I voted LHW. A Heavyweight, imo, would have posted something worthy of a Heavyweight vote.

[Axel]

Based solely on these three images, I voted LHW. A Heavyweight, imo, would have posted something worthy of a Heavyweight vote.

I dunno If i know what that means, but I appreciate the vote anyway.

[CopperPop]

I like what I see so far, As far a technique, I see heavy... I wish the Page had more action with Nightwing....

Based solely on these three images, I voted LHW. A Heavyweight, imo, would have posted something worthy of a Heavyweight vote.

This has me curious as well, For future reference, what do you mean?

[Popninja]

I dunno If i know what that means, but I appreciate the vote anyway.

http://www.penciljack.com/forum/show...e-weigh-in-(H)

This is typically what I think of when I think "HEAVYWEIGHT." Lots of people here want to vote Heavy for stuff that just is not HEAVY. If you've even got one person looking at your stuff and thinking, "Eh...middleweight," then you aren't a Heavyweight.

Your coloring skills are quite good, but these three images are not Heavy...imo.

[Axel]

I like what I see so far, As far a technique, I see heavy... I wish the Page had more action with Nightwing....

That's actually the first page of a sample I need to start over and finish, there are two pages of fighting still to be drawn. Thanks!

[Axel]

http://www.penciljack.com/forum/show...e-weigh-in-(H)

This is typically what I think of when I think "HEAVYWEIGHT." Lots of people here want to vote Heavy for stuff that just is not HEAVY. If you've even got one person looking at your stuff and thinking, "Eh...middleweight," then you aren't a Heavyweight.

Your coloring skills are quite good, but these three images are not Heavy...imo.

Thanks for clarifying, and I don't disagree - I was thinking I'd be more of a middleweight, honestly.

[Anthony ANMPH Hary]

Great reply.

I dunno If i know what that means, but I appreciate the vote anyway.

Looks like you could go either way, LHW or HW at this point. Good for you! I was looking forward to you being a HW and adding some competition to that level. But hey, if you get started as a LHW, you can rock that out and provide a good challenge no matter what.

Have fun man!

[Symson]

There are anatomy issues and backgrounds are good but not convincing in places. Coloring is a little mushy. I vote middle.

[Axel]

There are anatomy issues and backgrounds are good but not convincing in places. Coloring is a little mushy. I vote middle.

Can you elaborate on the anatomy issues? I don't hear that often, and I'd like to rectify any issues you noticed.