PSF - Hangman vs Solace - Shatterstar & Cable

[Solace]

Hangman



Solace



I'm going to learn to post polls properly the first time someday...

[Hanzou]

Had to go with Solace, even though I enjoyed hangman's comic.

Great work gentlemen.

[thordad]

I cant pick one at the moment . Im gonna have to chew on it for a day .

Solace thats a great piece ( I actually liked it better in the BW stage )

Hangman , There are great spots in your piece ( I know you got crunched for time ) there are few spots that dont flow as well for me.

There is also a similarity to the styles at play here . makes it a tough choice.

Great work guys.

[Hangman]

Solace- Great Piece man!love the characters emotions and the movement throughout this. And ur colors do a great job of added dimension. This was lots of fun and I hope to see you in battle once again.

[Popninja]

Damn, Solace! Color made all the difference on yours. Awesome work. Hangman's looks very rushed and the word balloons seem like an afterthought.

My vote goes to Solace.

[MrBojangles]

Solace, I think you need to keep their eyes above the center line of the page to keep the composition balanced. You've cut Cable and Shatterstar off at the ankles as well, something you should avoid doing. It looks great though, I wouldn't have colored it though, the B&W had so much more kick!

[StudioMe]

Solace's Shatterstar is great, the Cable unbalances the piece a bit, not as well done , coloring is excellent, but I Hangman's story telling and balance win my vote. Long live X-Force

[Selkirk]

tough one...went with solace here. great background(very nice details)...it actually looks like a warehouse. oh and the pouch work(hey all x-force chars had at least 10 pouches) is top notch. hangman i like what im seeing very nice sequential...but solace outpouched you.

[Hangman]

Im adding more pouches as we speak!!!!!!!!!! :P

[Selkirk]

in the words of the human torch 'pouch on'...mmm that may have been rob liefeld