PSF-NickGuy vs. Slam:Batman and Robin

[NickRocks]

Slam



NickGuy

[NickRocks]

ugh just realized that i didnt set an end date. can a mod fix that pls k thx.

[NickRocks]

interesting piece slam, wouldve loved to see it finished! like how we both used splatter, lolz.

I went with a cartoony, kirbyesque DK2 style, so its interesting to go up against what you brought. robin and batman seem to be in two seperate pics here...i can almost hear batman going "stop posing and HELP ME, boy!" lol. your batman has a wedgie, and joker is wearing such baggy clothes lol. i wish your batman wouldve been as nice as your robin, that couldve been epic.

!

[alfred183]

Slam! That's so awesome!! Got my vote.

Nick, I love the hair on your Robin's legs. lol

Great job to both!

[NickRocks]

lol yeah, i chose the end scene of DK2 for my piece.

[slam]

Yeah my piece came together by coincidence. I drew Batman hitting Joker as a sketch but i really liked it, so I went with it, then only had the corner for Robin to fill. I was thinking of widening the angle so I could fit Robin fighting Harley, but no time. Oh and yeah Batman forgot to put on his underpants so it's a bit tight
I like the platters in yours. I should've done some aswell for the blood instead of just drawing them.

I normally only draw my own creations, but this was really fun! Now I'm hooked, want to do more of these

[thordad]

WOW , wildly different takes on these characters.

My only problem with each of these pieces is Robin .

Slams Robin I dont understand how he fits into the picture ( though beautifully rendered)
Nicks Robin the face kills for me what was another wise very interesting Robin
THat said you both had kick butt Bat Man
My votes going to have to go to Slam on this one.

[alfred183]

FYI, an afro-Robin may have gotten my vote

[NickRocks]

Nicks Robin the face kills for me what was another wise very interesting Robin .

hes supposed to be a grown up...hence the older face and hairy legs.

[Popninja]

For me, the left bicep on Nick's Batman killed any possibility of me being able to vote for his piece. I just can't get past it. I get the whole Miller-esque vibe you shoot for in most of your work, but every once in a while, when you're just arbitrarily brushing that ink on, you have to step back and check to make sure things are going right. That bicep is just 317 kinds of wrong. And yeah, Robin's face doesn't help either.

I voted for slam. Good piece. Not perfect, by any stretch. The only off thing for me is that I don't believe Batman's right arm, if pulled back, would actually go past his ass.