PTR1: Bathill8 vs. ScottEwen

[ScottEwen]

The topic is a character from Bone teamed up with a character from Justice League International (or "Formerly Known as the Justice League" or "I Can't Believe It's Not the Justice League").

Bathill8


ScottEwen

[shawny]

this was incredibly tough! two very different styles - it's almost impossible to compare... but i did and went with scott on this.

[Dr. Baltar]

Voted for Bathill8, I dig his pencils.

[C William Russette]

Very, very close. Like both styles. Had to go with Bat.

[thEbrEEze]

bats made me smile, nice pencils

[adultbraces]

I LOVED this topic!! Great showing from both, but Bathill won me over. Nice pencils, and I'm a sucker for Booster Gold.

[Telekinetic Ketchup]

to be honest this isn't the best I've seen from either of you, scott your girls look like old ladies facially and thorns bent leg looks kinda iffy. And Bat your Phoney looks like a child with a mask and it kind of creeps the hell out of me.

I do love Scotts inking though so had to go with Scotty.

[Bathill8]

Nice job, Scott! You'r backgrounds even have some Jeff Smith in them, man! ...and I was hoping you didn't finish yours off with colors *whew*!

Thanks for the comments and votes guys.

[dfbovey]

I liked them both, but ended up going with Scott because of the overall composition and use of background. I do agree with TK about the old lady faces though.

Bathill, I do love your rendering, clean pencils and style! The facial expressions are really nice.

[Jared Lee]

I liked bother works but I voited for Bathill8 because he showed the topic the clearest.