PSF: JC Immortal vs. ScottEwen

[ScottEwen]

JC Immortal


ScottEwen

[ENTITY]

I voted with Scott on this because it has a very Mike Allred style to it that I really dig.

Good "fight", guys!

[Captain All That]

Went with JC... because that hulk looks like he can kick anus...

[Teratophile]

I went with scotts cause his hulk is in the process of kicking anus.

[Popninja]

I don't really care at all for Scott's depiction of the Hulk here, but there's no denying that his entry is better than he competitor's.

[ScottEwen]

I don't really care at all for Scott's depiction of the Hulk here,

What don't you like about it? The cartoony style?

[Popninja]

What don't you like about it? The cartoony style?

That might be it. Something about the look on his face just doesn't work for me. As a whole, though, it's really good work.

[ScottEwen]

That might be it. Something about the look on his face just doesn't work for me. As a whole, though, it's really good work.

Thanks... I've never drawn the Hulk before so maybe that's it. He doesn't look as primate-like as he probably should, I just gave him a normal dude's face.

[Breck]

Well, on one hand, Scott's piece has action and a complete background. On the other hand, the point was to draw the Hulk, and Scott's Hulk just seems way off to me. The pose is sort of like he's skipping through the forest, and everything from the neck up just doesn't say Hulk at all. So I had to give it to JC. The theme was the Hulk and his Hulk is superior.

[NickGuy]

yeah this one is jc immortal for me. i dont like scotts hulks pose or lower body =\