Redone Sequentials Draw-off: Round Three (K.O.- therealArturo)

[ScottEwen]

The point of this draw-off was to redo a page of sequentials that was at least five years old. Please vote for who you think has improved the most, and please don't vote for yourself. Higher resolution versions of the pages are linked underneath the thumbnails.

therealArturo

Original - Redone

larq2525

Original - Redone

cold-blooded-angel

Original - Redone

Honorable mention: CarlosArtWrx
http://i15.photobucket.com/albums/a3...sartwrx2-1.jpg

[bindlestitch]

I just wanted to say that all three of you did an excellent job on these. It's cool to see how much you've advanced.

[SilverSkies]

I Vote therealArturo, he really did cool....

[CarlosArtWrx]

Honorable mention: CarlosArtWrx
http://i15.photobucket.com/albums/a3...sartwrx2-1.jpg

Thanks for the mention. Sorry to back out... I just felt that the page was not to the point of where I wanted it to be.

[Archerion]

CBA i think your older ones are better than the new ones.

[cold-blooded-angel]

my older one is 2004. and the newer one is unfinished. I really didn't expect it to be put up for voting because of that.

[hydekomiksink]

I went with TheRealArturo - His storytelling really improved. His camera angles got better. His page layout streamlined - and he added backrounds in his panels wich lent a new sense of realism to his work. Very nice!

[ScottEwen]

my older one is 2004. and the newer one is unfinished. I really didn't expect it to be put up for voting because of that.

Oops, sorry, CBA, I didn't realize you didn't want this put up for voting. Although the page was supposed to be five years old, so it shouldn't have qualified anyway, but... oh well.

[cold-blooded-angel]

true, I hadn't ever written a comic before that one, I should have asked.

[ScottEwen]

true, I hadn't ever written a comic before that one, I should have asked.

Well in the first round I made an exception that if you didn't have sequential pages at least five years old, you could do your oldest ones. So it's fine. I still would have put the pages up for polling no matter what, even if you used a page you did a week ago, but I didn't realize you didn't want it included in the poll. Sorry again.