Hulk vs Deathlok/Phil Clark vs Morganza Battle (K.O.- Phil Clark)

**Phil Clark** · 02-24-2003, 06:26 PM

Ok. Both contestants have finished their art. So here we go.

Phil Clark's art:

Morganza's Art:

You know the drill. So, who wins this battle?

LET'S GET IT ON!

**Meta-Knight** · 02-24-2003, 06:39 PM

went with Phil...I like the action and the clear view of both characters....Deathlok kicks ass X3

**PizzatheHutt3000** · 02-24-2003, 07:58 PM

I Had to go with Mongaza's.

Phil Clarks is nice I admit but three areas make me go to Morganza's as the winner of my vote.

First is the hand on DeathLok, this sticks out like a sore thumb as being just as long as his forearm. Also, the leg on our left has an awkward curve, it looks like it would fit better on the opposite leg with an opposite foot. Third is the Hulks back, I'd really like to see rounded or more obvious muscle on the Hulk, it looks like he almost has a sag in one area specifically. As a minor and not so important area, the hand going into the wall could use more effort , maybe just a hint of a thumb.

On the otherhand...

Morganza's has no flaw that hits me over the head...or even really hints to me, he has a great Hulk and those robots really add a nice touch. As a matter of fact the only thing I can find to crit on Morganza's pic is the Hulks haircut.

great job to both, but Morganza wins this one hands down, IMHO.

**InkDrop** · 02-24-2003, 10:08 PM

Originally posted by PizzatheHutt3000
As a matter of fact the only thing I can find to crit on Morganza's pic is the Hulks haircut.

great job to both, but Morganza wins this one hands down, IMHO.

Agreed. Hulks hair makes him look a bit like clark kent...lol...but nice job both of you.

PEACE,
Drop

Juan · 02-24-2003, 10:37 PM

I like them both. I think you both did a good job on this challenge.

I like Phil's because of the action packed framework, but I also like Morgan's because of all the extra characters in the piece...

...decisions, decisions...

*flips a quarter*

I'm not telling who I voted for.

;dvl;

**...o...k....** · 02-24-2003, 11:03 PM

I voted for Phil. Both had a lot of action but Phil drew my eye into the action. When I first looked at Morg's, it took me a while to see the action. I also don't really like the way Morg drew Hulk's face. Yeah, that's a bad reason but there it is.

**Rey de las Cabras** · 02-24-2003, 11:32 PM

There things I like about both and things that really really bother me about both, but I'll save the crits for the drawing board I guess, if you guys post them up over there.

Morganza takes it for me after a long time debating it.

**mavra_aka_j9** · 02-24-2003, 11:55 PM

hej ya'll,

well, i voted for morg's
cos.... well, i concur with the issues noted by pizza
and 'sides that .... i do not like the mouth you drew on hulk or the haphazard way you have his head there phil. and the only thing i like in the piece is.... the face you gave deathlok
but, i really like the action in morg's
the arm rippin' thing got me