HEAVY WEIGHT CHAMPIONSHIP - NYP vs. JUGGERTHA - THANOS

[spidey976]

Voted Juggs on this one ... it just had more of a punch for me. NYP your piece is awesome, but given the subject matter I was expecting you to kick it up a notch and show one HELL of a battle.

[Fallenangel]

NYP's is better drawn, but very subdued. I was really hoping that with a HEAVYWEIGHT championship match, we would see some KILLER pieces from both of you.

I agree with every word here.

In the end voted for NYP.

Fallen.

[Walril]

NYP, the only thing thats bothering me (like I can really talk) is that death doesn't seem in the same plane as the other figures. Like the perspective is off. The scene is almost a top down and she is straight on.

I feel like i dont deserve to vote for this because its like a plumber without IT experience telling two IT guys are doing it wrong.

[ghostcat]

I also agree with Pop. NYP has the better piece, but it's boring.

[CrazyDiamond]

I voted for Jugga mainly because I have seen NYP do better. Whenever I see that NYP is competing I can't wait to click inside and see what has been done. I feel this one was not up to his usual standard.

[dfbovey]

I don't really understand that line of thinking in voting. This isn't Juggertha's best piece either. And they aren't completing against themselves, there's two pieces of art in this thread going head to head. You should be voting on these pieces. One or the other based on what's shown.

While I agree that it's not the most exiting, it looks like it could be a professional panel out of a comic. It's at a difficult angle, shows understanding of perspective. And that's why it ended up getting my vote.

[Keith]

I don't really understand that line of thinking in voting. This isn't Juggertha's best piece either. And they aren't completing against themselves, there's two pieces of art in this thread going head to head. You should be voting on these pieces. One or the other based on what's shown.

I mean, the main thing I'm reading here is NYP's piece isn't exciting or it's boring, while it's not wild in any way, it's well drawn overall.

But what's so exciting about a head shot with a hand next to it? Dunno, I'm truly stumped here.

[Fallenangel]

I mean, the main thing I'm reading here is NYP's piece isn't exciting or it's boring, while it's not wild in any way, it's well drawn overall.

But what's so exciting about a head shot with a hand next to it? Dunno, I'm truly stumped here.

I think what they mean by "exciting" is the original impact of the picture, Juggs piece is very well colored and at first glance stands out more compared to NYP's pic. That is why people tend vote for it.

[CrazyDiamond]

I don't really understand that line of thinking in voting. This isn't Juggertha's best piece either. And they aren't completing against themselves, there's two pieces of art in this thread going head to head. You should be voting on these pieces. One or the other based on what's shown.

Isn't it wonderful that we all get to have our own opinion and our own vote and get to use each as we want? Even though you can tell me how you think that I should think and vote you do not have the power to change it. Nor should you.

[dfbovey]

Isn't it wonderful that we all get to have our own opinion and our own vote and get to use each as we want? Even though you can tell me how you think that I should think and vote you do not have the power to change it. Nor should you.

Sure, as long as you'd like to continue to make no sense by voting for the reasons that you do.

I could change it if I wanted to. I could simply edit the poll. But that would be just as wrong as your mentality of not actually voting based on the pieces presented as they compare to each other, which is the entire point of the voting poll.