Juggs, nice paints on this one - I really like all the textures you worked into Spidey's costume. Fallen, totally love your Spiderman and background, looks awesome.
Both pieces have their strengths, I picked Fallen. Good work, gents.
I chose Fallen, because he was a bit more stronger technically.
However, Fallen, the background where it is much closer to Spider-man and the gang of young boys is rather on the weaker side, dimension-wise. It appears that you used one-point perspective throughout the entire illustration and applied it to the nearby background. If so, why? If you had used a proper 3-point perspective, you would have given your background a dimension that would have stolen the show.
Both of these are great. Ed's colors are top notch as always and he did a great job with the dynamic pose. But when Fallen brings the super tight pencils like that it's a tall order to beat him. For that reason and for the beautiful rendering he gets my vote.
I guess I look like a jackass for voting against Fallen. I would have followed everyone if I hadnt been jarred by the stiffness and symetry in the foreground thugs. The absolute only flaw in an otherwise very compelling piece, but it was a big one to me.
Ed's is spectacularly colored but there are some anatomy issues and perspective problems there as well.
It almost boils down to whether I want to vote for the great coloring or the great pencil work. Because they both have errors that cancel each other out.