Weaponsmith104 weigh in (L)

[weaponsmith104]

Can one of the Commish post my poll for me...thx.

[paintingfire]

Welcome!

I voted Lightweight- I see some great ideas and humor, and some really nice details (the flying bits of wall are fun!), and hey, backgrounds! But, the anatomy could use some practice (the center piece is getting there!) and the perspective is coming out flat.

I'm looking forward to seeing what you bring to pummel, Weaponsmith!

[weaponsmith104]

Thank you, and the crits were insightfull, any more would be appreciated. thx

[Sketchbook]

Cool work. I think you'll find some solid competition in Light Weight. I see a lot of promise in your work. Looking forward to seeing more of you in Pummel.

Welcome

[Joeydes]

Arrgh! Sorry man...I mis-clicked....I can see how easy it is to do that...was gonna vote light....love the humor.

[weaponsmith104]

lol, its cool and thx.

[Walril]

Im gonna say LW, mostly because of anatomy issues. Welcome.

[Popninja]

weaponsmith104, you are really young, and that can be both a blessing and a curse. A blessing because at your age, you're a sponge, willing to soak up every bit of knowledge available and possibly grow much faster than an older guy would. But a curse in that, also at that age, the ego can trip you up and getting the low vote in a competition can sometimes bruise that ego. I hope you're prepared for serious competition and sharp criticisms.

I wish you lots of luck. I really like the energy in that Hulk/Thing piece.

I voted lightweight.

[weaponsmith104]

thanks i really appreciate the crits, i already knew i was gonna get light weight though. But thats the main reason i joined is so that i could get better, especialy at my anatomy. Im open to all crits

[spidey976]

Hey waponsmith I see a lot of potential here, and a lot of room to grow as long as you keep that great attitude you have going.

Firstly, I would sa that you should look up the work of Jack Hamm, and Andrew Loomis. They both did some great anatomy reference books. Hamms Head and Afigure is relatively cheap and you can find it online or in many bookstores. As for Loois his work is out of print, but you should be able to find it in PDF form on the net.

Secondly, while I do recommend that you look for reference material be careful to make sure that you give credit for the reference, and at you READ the referencing rules for PUMMEL carefully. I only bring it up because I am PRETTY sure you used a reference for that Hulk vs Thing piece (Ed Mguiness Hulkd vs Red Hulk am I right???), and you will. Get called on it