PRM LW's Reggie vs AJ - MoonKnight

[ReggieR3mote]

Round 4 Between RR+Karp and it looks like both came to fight tonight folks
In the MOON corner we have AjKarp:

and in the Knight corner we have ReggieR3mote


alright boys lets keep this a clean fight no pencils below the belt, no ink in yer gloves, and no drawing past the bell...
LET'S GET IT ON!

[ajkarp]

LOL thanks Reg!

[ReggieR3mote]

No prob Karp, your figure work is really coming around man. They're loosening up less stiff more natural good work buddy.

[Emperorsteele]

On one hand, I like both of these for different reasons. AJ's has a bit of action and is a more complete piece, while RR's is clean with some nice figure work. I like the composition of both pieces equally. However, I feel both artists could have done better. AJ needs a bit of work on his figures (MK's extended arm really bothers me), and RR's background is rather underwhelming. The moon looks great, but i almost feel the buildings hurt the piece more than help it.

I'm gonna wait a day or so before voting, I need to think about this one...

[BringerOfStorms]

Cool work on both pieces. It was close but I went with AjKarp for a more complete presentation (although I think I like Reggies character design better).

Keep it up guys. Good work!

~BoS

[Juggertha]

AJ, really nice work on the composition, but man, I really wish you would tighten up on some of the details. The anatomy and faces go a bit beyond stylistic choice.

RR, I like the anatomy and stylistic choice, but the whole piece really lacks impact. I think you skimped far too much on the background details... Namely, that gradient he's standing on.

Tough call on this one as I like them both for very different reasons.

[immigrant]

man oh man oh man goodstuff good stuff

[ReggieR3mote]

seriously after having to fight so many times already i'm starting to think we're gonna be trying to kick each other's asses until we're graduating from the HW ranks.