Topic: Iconic comic moment of your choice.
Chris McJunkin: Death of Phoenix
President: Death of Superman
Chris, that is possibly the best piece I've seen from ya. I'm loving it. Not loving that it looks like Scott's got Jean's hair in a vice grip, but loving the rest of it.
Prez, is she crying because Supes is dead, or because his body is all messed up? lol
GREAT work on the girl...frakkin awesome, actually. But I think you mangled Supes.
My Deviant Art page
My PUMMEL stats
PUMMEL stats: 56 wins | 49 losses | 30 KOs
2 Time Heavyweight Champion
Light Heavyweight Commissioner
yeah i was like holy crap that's chris' best piece so far and the I see president's and im like aw man chris' is so good but Im gonna have to vote against him. then I do a double take and notice superman's body.
Raised as a babe in drawing arenas to become the art warrior that I am today.
http://gunkstudios.tumblr.com/
Pummel: lightheavy weight rank- wins-27 losses-20 KO-11
I actually like President's layout, composition and energy more. But major point deductions for Superman's anatomy/proportions and lack of finish. I really like the expression on her face, and her hair.
Chris, Really conveys emotion very well. Some nice inks, but I kinda wish you had made Scott and Jean larger and in the forefront giving it more impact, maybe with the other characters ghosted in the background conveying the same emotions. Jean could also have used a looser gesture.
See my work on the Game of Thrones season 2 Bluray features "Legends and Lore"
My Deviant Art Page
PUMMEL Statistics: Wins: 22 Losses: 3 Knockouts: 15
Six Time Heavyweight Champion - Original Tournament Winner - 5 Time Hall of Fame inductee
Yeah, Chris wins this one for me.
As others have said - Pres' piece looks fantastic until you actually concentrate on Superman's anatomy.
Help fund my comic on INDIEGOGO!!
(I'm offering all kinds of cool packages in return)
www.deanbeattie.com
My Twitter
Aaaargh. Yes. I really like Chris', and I think I'm ultimately going to have to vote for it. But I REALLY WANT to vote for President's. It's a really excellent picture, aside from the unfortunate proportion issues.
Chris I love your composition - has emotional weight. This is my favorite piece from you that I've seen.
Wow Chris sweet cover design. Very well done. Not to beat a dead horse, but had Supes body been on point this woulda been much closer.
Love the energy in Prez's piece. I wish it was finished and not so flawed.
I voted Chris, but I disagree with anyone saying this is McJunkin's best work. It is good, but not great. Chris, you left out a character from this iconic moment.
Money can't buy you happiness, but it will pay for the search.
Wow both chose great moments in comic history...and both cranked out wonderful work, I had to take a day to actually decide...great stuff yall
Pummel stats W -10 | L - 15 | KO - 5 | CH - 0
Posting Permissions
Bookmarks