Pummel Middleweight: Ekotek vs Alexcat321- The Avengers

[alexcat321]

Here's Ekotek's entry:
Page1:

Page2:

Page3:


Here's Alexcat321's:

[alexcat321]

I need my mistake to be undone, I accidentally voted for myself in trying to vote for ekotek. I need some assistance. Btw, nice job Ekotek.

[ekotek]

I need my mistake to be undone, I accidentally voted for myself in trying to vote for ekotek. I need some assistance. Btw, nice job Ekotek.

Hey, no problem, I think -- I'll vote for myself, and we can call it even
Nice work to you too Alexcat -- it was a real blast having you as a competitor this month!!

[alexcat321]

Thanks man, I appreciate the appreciation. I could've done better tho. It was a pleasure having u as well.

[JC Immortal]

Wow a day early! i guess if u added color this would have been harder to decide cause u both have similar styles ...just looks like Ekotek put in more work...though i luv your spidey! almost gave the vote to u cause of him

[alexcat321]

Thanks JC, appreciate it!

[necenarro]

You can tell both pieces have a lot of work-- 3 pages of sequential?! I'm not sure I could do it, but big props to both for doing them.

I think you guys could learn a lot from each other, Alex looking at Eko's colors (if you do that) and Eko looking at Alex's panel varying compositions (i.e. wide establishing and close up shots). I liked Eko putting in dialogue.

I'm going to stare at these for 24 hours and then decide.

[Juggertha]

Great work here guys - but do me a favor and make the poll visible next time.

[pigeonmilk]

Dang I was wanting to see how ekotcs finished out! You left us with a cliffhanger there. Vision takes off, Wasp getting ready to attack..

[slam]

Alex: You should've put dialogue man, it feels kind of lost without it. If you were going to post something without dialogue you should've just kept it to action, did you run out of time?
Ekotek: Overall feel this is much more complete, even though I'm not fond of the dialogue, it's a bit over dramatic for my taste, and the text is crammed into little boxes, it's not wrong in this case to have a look at your favourite comics and copy the way they do their balloons. There usually is a lot more breathing space around the text because reading 50 pages like that is very tiring for the eyes in my oppinion.

Very impressive that you both went all out on 3 pages!