PSF: Richdraws vs Manji - Daredevil

[Manji]

richdraws





Manji

[Manji]

Great piece Rich

[Juggertha]

Rich, this is massive step up from your weigh-in.

http://www.penciljack.com/forum/show...00822-Weigh-in

I really don't think those pieces represented you. You need to be a Heavy.

[iSiT]

I have to vote Manji by a hair. Rich, you nailed the mood to the wall, but I felt there were a few minor proportion issues where I just felt Manji was stronger with his piece.

I, being me, tried to make the consistency of buckles and straps my deciding factor, but you both had issues there too.

Both of you should be proud of the work you've done, cause in the end you both won IMHO.

[kae_ae]

Dig rich's, tho I don't dig the pose and some minor fundamental flaws (left hand finger lengths). But gorgeous lighting/mood.

[k0b13]

Great piece both both. Going to vote for rich though. Btw the perspective distortion in Rich's piece is way too much considering distance from camera, or am I wrong?

[richdraws]

Great work Manji, quite a lot of work to do in the short deadline you set! DD looks like he is taking a few hits there. I was expecting to see Electra in yours somewhere...

Why do people not like the forced perspective? I quite like it but probably need to study more skate photography - they have lots of good warped action shots.

[Jeloschi]

Looks like the champ's gettin' his ass kicked... by a middleweight. (I am so on the list now:P)

[kae_ae]

Great work Manji, quite a lot of work to do in the short deadline you set! DD looks like he is taking a few hits there. I was expecting to see Electra in yours somewhere...

Why do people not like the forced perspective? I quite like it but probably need to study more skate photography - they have lots of good warped action shots.

If you reference skate photos then you'll notice your background is too 'flat' in comparison. That kind of foreshortening of the figure would result in a fish eye lens effect to the background.

[Doomsmith]

Rich you sandbaggin' SOB! Not bad. You should go after RaHavok next......






D2k10!