Pummel Weigh-in

[Chris Major]

Back to PJ for freestyle Pummelling.
Your call, ladies and gentlemen:

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2640/3703185758_570809ef5f_o.jpg

[ntat]

i chose middle, but i think u r actually right in the really high middle, low heavy area. awesom work man.

[Tragikdj911]

great style, great detail, slap some ink down and print! This gets the Heavyweight seal.

[thordad]

Great piece , rendering is tight as can be hoped for , anatomy is really good even in perspective but there are areas in both that lean me to say middleweight Flash isnt always substance and substance isnt much without flash ( a lesson Im swallowing every time out , but loving the progressive results )

Middleweight my friend and welcome to the Fray

[Jared Lee]

I've colored your work for ASJ41 so I know your a heavy weight.:D

[hadesillustrations]

I voted middleweight. This is a nice finished piece, but your girl on the board has no right leg. She has a right butt cheek and a right foot, but what happened to her leg?

[Chris Major]

From where I'm standing, it's perspective, Hades. :)

[Ebernaught]

From where I'm standing, it's perspective, Hades. :)

A very good piece, no doubt,but I agree with Hades in respect to foot position.Definitely high middleweight though!:lml-: :-lml:

[Popninja]

I voted middleweight, even though some aspects of this piece make me think lightweight. Your composition and attention to detail put you right in the middleweight category, but your rendering, to some degree, drop you down a peg.

And that right leg should be in there, especially from that angle. It wouldn't be completely hidden like that.

[NickRocks]

rendering says heavyweight-ish, anatomy and underdrawing say lightweight...i voted middle! :)

[StudioMe]

Good piece , lots of detail. I do agree on the missing portion of leg , but it is a solid picture and I appreciate great pencil work , so Middleweight is my vote.

[slam]

I voted middleweight aswell. I think you need a push to improve your drawing skills. This is quite an ambitious piece of work and it revealed a lot of your weaknesses. But that's I think what makes you middleweight, the fact that you try and draw these very challenging poses. Stick to your strenghts and you're sure not to improve right? I really like your linework and I loved the way you rendered the waves. The perspective unfortunatly is not pulled off, that foreshortening on the front leg is wrong, looks like a shoe with no power leg, those folds on her trousers are wrong aswell, and the surfboard looks like a piece of paper. Still these are things you can improve by sudying anatomy, and life drawing. Welcome to the club major.