PSF: NickGuy vs Selkirk

[NickRocks]

the topic was conan the barbarians girlfriend, Belit

NickGuy
http://i93.photobucket.com/albums/l48/NickGuy_2006/PUMMELstreetfight3WIP-1.gif

Selkirk
http://i627.photobucket.com/albums/tt360/Selkirk/belit.jpg

[thEbrEEze]

Great work from u both! I voted for nick cause it gives off a frank millar vibe. I think sel's piece would have been better without medusa in it.

Hey nick, do u ink digitally?

[Popninja]

Honestly, I would hardly call either of these "great work." It still looks like it takes NickGuy five minutes to draw the stuff he posts.

I voted for Selkirk because his Belit looks more like an actual woman than NickGuy's. And since both of these fall in the category of sketches, that was the only criteria I had to go on.

[NickRocks]

yes this was digital..why? i recently got a tablet pc last month and have been messing with that since then.

[NickRocks]

I voted for Selkirk because his Belit looks more like an actual woman than NickGuy's.


really? how does mine look less womanly? :confused:

[Popninja]

really? how does mine look less womanly? :confused:

I meant facially. I should have specified.

[ENTITY]

Honestly, I would hardly call either of these "great work." It still looks like it takes NickGuy five minutes to draw the stuff he posts.

I voted for Selkirk because his Belit looks more like an actual woman than NickGuy's. And since both of these fall in the category of sketches, that was the only criteria I had to go on.

I tend to agree on these points. I would very much like to see what both of these artists could do if they spent some real time on their work.

Nick,her face is seriously a villainous dude face, and her arms are crazy big for a female. Maybe if her eyebrows were separately defined from the shadowed eye socket it could've worked.

[NickRocks]

I tend to agree on these points. I would very much like to see what both of these artists could do if they spent some real time on their work.

Nick,her face is seriously a villainous dude face, and her arms are crazy big for a female. Maybe if her eyebrows were separately defined from the shadowed eye socket it could've worked.

interesting...thanks for that, i dont normally draw muscular women, and this was a first drawing conans gf! so thanks for that crit. and about the face, i see it now.

[angeltread]

oh shit... do i go for the naked boobs or the bigger boobs.... dammit the choice is just too hard.

[Jared Lee]

oh shit... do i go for the naked boobs or the bigger boobs.... dammit the choice is just too hard.

I'm leaning for Nick because of the naked boobs, but I'll have to put a bit more thought into it before I cast my vote.

[CoreyPledger]

props for boobage, homie. Nick all the way.

[CoreyPledger]

HA what a backtrack.

All this artisticly creative criticism going on and suddenly myself, Jared Lee and Angeltread start harking on about "Beautiful tracts of land."

Guy humor.

[adultbraces]

had to go with the Miller-esque turn out from Nick guy. good job, both of you.

[NickRocks]

hahaha WOW this ones close. thanks for accepting my challenge selkirk youre putting up a great fight!

[Selkirk]

yeah its going pretty good...nice back and forth-good match so far. will be a better match if i win of course :D.

[angeltread]

boobs are very serious for me

[NickRocks]

...looks like im going to lose by 2 votes haha. way to go selkirk.

[Selkirk]

you're only down one vote...still could win :pj:

[Selkirk]

hey thanks for the brawl nick...good fight :pj:

[NickRocks]

i agree! hopefully ill see you in the tournament sometime.