PDA

View Full Version : Akira



DJ Kenobi
02-24-2005, 11:13 PM
Akira: Volumes 1-6
By Katsuhiro Otomo

Warning: There are some spoilers in here. Read at your own discretion.

I finally got around to reading Akira. I was always missing a volume, or didn’t think I’d have time to read it straight through, or some other excuse. But I finally read all 6 volumes in the past 2 days and it was absolutely amazing. The art is astoundingly gorgeous. I can’t praise it enough. What struck me most was Otomo’s pacing and storytelling. I never thought I’d be able to say this about something, but the last 1000 pages just fly by at a breakneck pace. To keep the story moving so fast with so many characters and so many plotlines is the real amazing aspect of Akira, IMHO. Yes, the art is beautiful. Yes, the story is not only captivating plot wise, but the characters excellent. On top of all that though, a 2000+ page story that really reads as one cohesive piece is a true testament to impeccable plotting.

One comparison I couldn’t help but make while reading Akira was to Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, for obvious reasons. Otomo seems to go one step further than Shelley though, increasing the moral ambiguity of the characters while decreasing the direct didacticism of story itself. There is even less of a sense of good versus evil in Akira than in Frankenstein. Shelley’s book seems to set out to teach Dr. Frankenstein a lesson, that all life is precious, and she uses the “monster” as her rod to beat that into him. But in the end, the world is not changed. Dr. Frankenstein is dead and the creature leaves, to burn himself and his creator atop a funeral pyre in the arctic. The book remains as the “text” for the lesson the good doctor learns, and therefore we are supposed to learn. However in Akira, effective change is a constant. Neo-Tokyo is destroyed multiple times, the geo-political climate of much of the world is changed, and even the moon does not escape unscathed. Yet, is there a lesson to learn from Akira? Are we intended to learn the lesson that Dr. Frankenstein intends the ship captain and his biographer, Walton, to learn? That uncontrolled ambition leads to self-destruction? That reading is very possible from Akira, as the government that creates Tetsuo and Akira is destroyed by their creations. Yet Kaneda is just as ambitious and ends up leading what remains of the Great Tokyo Empire at the end. He gets the girl, gets the bike, and gets the city. The only price he pays is the lives of his friends Tetsuo and Yamagata. This sort of character development goes across the board in Akira. The Colonel is the bad guy for the first half the series, then a neutral, an ally, and finally retires into obscurity. Characters are controlled by their personalities and their history, not by the artifice of good versus evil. This is quite the achievement for an epic story, which by nature usually requires a villain and a hero.

Akira is a story of building through deconstruction, making it for me, the best piece of postmodern literature I’ve read.

chynco
02-25-2005, 01:18 AM
wow, that was an amazing review.

All I can say is... ditto!

Super Rats
02-25-2005, 06:51 AM
That was a nice review! I like the comparison to Frankenstein, never looked at it that way.

Otomo's execution on Akira is absolutely nuts, but most importantly it's one hell of a ride.

Ed
02-25-2005, 07:31 AM
so...i should read it?




it was cool when keneda had the laser in the anime.

Vargas Prime
02-25-2005, 08:06 AM
so...i should read it?




it was cool when keneda had the laser in the anime.

Yes, you should read it. But, since you've seen the movie, DON'T go into the comic with any expectations from the anime.

They are so different, they're almost like alternative interpretations of the same basic elements. They had to alter so much of the content of the comic series to make an effective movie that it's better to think of them as two completely separate incarnations. If you start trying to compare the two, one of them will probably wind up disappointing you severely. At least that's been my experience with people I've gotten to read Akira.

K.E. Woolfork
02-25-2005, 09:09 AM
I always thought the anime was one of the MOST significant films out there. Deep and exciting and most impressive for a 'cartoon'.

I read voume one of the manga and it literally blows the movie out of the water. And that's just volume one.

Then remember there are five MORE perfectly executed volumes.

Yes, read them.

K.

Ichbin Der Ausgang
02-25-2005, 09:15 AM
Yes, you should read it. But, since you've seen the movie, DON'T go into the comic with any expectations from the anime.

They are so different, they're almost like alternative interpretations of the same basic elements. They had to alter so much of the content of the comic series to make an effective movie that it's better to think of them as two completely separate incarnations. If you start trying to compare the two, one of them will probably wind up disappointing you severely. At least that's been my experience with people I've gotten to read Akira.
they had to make changes due to time but also keep in mind akira the comic was not finished when akira the anime was released
It should be looked at as an adaptation. Not a translation


And it always gets me when someone (especially an artist!) says they havent read akira yet.
Im sure the libraries in every major city have them, so do yourself a favor and read them asap!!

DrVictorVonDoom
02-25-2005, 11:30 AM
I started reading them at the library when the first two or three had come out, and then started buying them. They're not only worth reading, they're worth owning.

Very nice analysis/argument, DJ.

DJ Kenobi
02-25-2005, 11:53 AM
Thanks.

Part of what took me so long to read them was some bad luck in getting the entire series. First I tried buying all the Epic issues way back when the end of the series was first being released in America, but was only able to find about 2/3 of the series. Then I tried buying all the hand-numbered hardcovers, I have volumes 2-5; could never find 1 and 6. So this summer I gave up the search and bought the dark horse softcovers. Now it's joined Watchmen on my short list of things that I'll read every year.

NickRocks
02-26-2005, 08:38 AM
I read voume one of the manga and it literally blows the movie out of the water. And that's just volume one.

Then remember there are five MORE perfectly executed volumes.

Yes, read them.

K.


VERY TRUE!

i read the first volume one night at a barnes and nobles, and i was amazed. i honestly thought that was it, so i bought volume 1. then a couple months later i saw there was a volume 2 and i was like "omg wtf".

Knigge
03-02-2005, 11:41 PM
I bought the hardback edition from Barnes and Noble (and released by Barnes and Noble Books) about a month or two ago because it was ironically less than the softcover. I just now started reading it about a week ago, so I'll chime in once I'm finished. I'm reading The Da Vinci Code at the same time, so gimme a week or two. I don't like to be rushed.
I will say that the movie is one of my favorite movies ever, which is why I was reluctant to read the manga. But now I don't care. I just want to read it and get a tiny bit more backstory, since I always thought the movie was really ambiguous, although that's one of the main reasons why I like it.

Knigge
03-08-2005, 09:31 PM
Holy shit, that first volume was amazing. I need to get the others. Thinking about the depth of the movie and reading that first volume makes me fiend for more. (However, it doesn't make me think less of the movie. Quite the opposite.) The intense detail in combination with the simplicity is mind boggling. Must have more.

NickRocks
03-09-2005, 05:54 AM
told ya. just wait till you get to three. that one was my favorite.

Ichbin Der Ausgang
03-09-2005, 10:13 AM
told ya. just wait till you get to three. that one was my favorite.

5 I believe is the breadwinner, artwise

NickRocks
03-09-2005, 11:25 AM
yeah, but 3 had the coolest action.

Kingsley
03-09-2005, 11:45 PM
Dj, I recently re-watched the movie to get an inspiration for this class project. But after I watched it I wanted to read the books again because I never got past volume three.
I started reading it yesterday and I have all the volumes now. I highly agree with you, Akira is the greatest thing ever.

Reilly
03-21-2005, 05:47 PM
Alright, this is something that I've noticed while reading Akira, but I've never heard anyone else point it out nor seen it confirmed anywhere, so I'm not entirely sure-- Akira is an adaptation of The Revelation of St. John, right?
I've never actually studied them side by side, and Akira is certainly apocalyptic, but it's also the Apocalypse, isn't it?

If it is or not, next time you read either one, keep the other in mind-- the similarites are very interesting.

--Reilly

TheFightingFoetus
08-31-2005, 09:11 AM
Good review, DJ. I agree, Akira is one to read multiple times, much like Watchmen, and I'd also say Ronin. (Which if nobody has posted a review of, I might have to get to sometime.)

Inkthinker
09-02-2005, 12:01 AM
Alright, this is something that I've noticed while reading Akira, but I've never heard anyone else point it out nor seen it confirmed anywhere, so I'm not entirely sure-- Akira is an adaptation of The Revelation of St. John, right?
I've never actually studied them side by side, and Akira is certainly apocalyptic, but it's also the Apocalypse, isn't it?

If it is or not, next time you read either one, keep the other in mind-- the similarites are very interesting.

--Reilly

I have no idea what you're talking about. Elaborate, my good son. I skimmed Revelations quite recently (KJV), and while it's full of interesting bits that certainly make for easy adaptations (golden cities, flaming spears, plagues, dead walking, etc.) I don't much recall anything that brough Akira to mind.

Reilly
09-02-2005, 07:22 AM
Hmm, well it's been a while since I've read either one, and a while since I typed that, but there are a few similarites that I still remember. All of the specific details are different, like Tetsuo's number is 41, not 666, and Kaneda's bike is red, not white, but the concepts are the same, you know? Tetsuo's head is injured, and he became huge and bizzare (even though he didn't specifically have 7 lepard heads), and he was certainly the false prophet of Akira. The bikers are sort of like the four horsemen (can't remember if there were four or not, but I don't think that really matters), Kaneda's like Jesus (err. . . was that Jesus in Revelations? I can't even remember) because of the way he keeps dying and comeing back to life, and his "flaming sword" and everything. Sol's fire from heaven. . . There was something about Takashi's death, too, and I remember something about after the city was destroyed and the people were dividing themselves up into tribes that I thought was similar. . .
Hmm, I don't remember everything now, but when I first noticed it I thought it was pretty damn cool.

Revelations is so damn wierd that I think it's possible for someone to do an adaptation of it and no one would even notice unless it was pointed out, you know? I could be way off base with that analysis, but it is pretty cool.

--Reilly

theGOBLIN
09-05-2005, 09:28 AM
Yeah Reily I see where the correlations are. Its been a while since I saw the movie and read those verses but I did really study them in an idea to some day do my own version of the apocalypse. I definitely see what your seeing with similar points.