View Full Version : Scalpel Color-off (K.O. - Shpydir)
.......although I already sent 2 of them off, those being Babycakes and Sara Crofts. Vote now so I can decide whether I send off Shpydirs or my own. Feel free to crit them also and please list your favorite one(s).
'Scalpel Widescreen' by FIG & Sara Croft (http://www.renderosity.com/homepage.ez?Who=FIG&ViewArticle=1475)
'Scalpel Widescreen' by FIG & Babycakes (http://www.renderosity.com/homepage.ez?Who=FIG&ViewArticle=1596)
'Scalpel Widescreen' by FIG & Shpydir (http://www.renderosity.com/homepage.ez?Who=FIG&ViewArticle=1613)
'Scalpel Widescreen' by FIG (http://www.renderosity.com/homepage.ez?Who=FIG&ViewArticle=1624)
10-15-2002, 10:10 AM
Soo...hard... to choose! Can't you send them both??
No only 3 entries are allowed and I already sent Babycakes and Saras.
I hate you. I voted for the wronge person cause of the ay you wrote out the pole. Damn reverse psycology.
So who would you vote for then if you could all over?
10-15-2002, 10:23 PM
Yeah, who did you want to vote for?
No pressure. :p
That's a pretty cool coloring there, FIGster. Lots of stuff to like.
Man.. I'm sorry Shpydir. I tried to vote for yours, but it seemed somewhat bland compared to what I know you can do. Plus, the way you recolored the linework on the girdle and boots threw me off, being that the lines are now a lighter color than both the boot color and the background color.
I voted for Fig's.
10-16-2002, 02:05 AM
I went with Shpydir's. Both were very well done. Shpydir's pic seemed to "pop" against the background a little better, so I went with it. I really only found one major fault with each pic, and this may just go down as my own personal tastes, but... I didn't like that Shpydir recolored the linework in parts of his, and I wasn't fond of the highlight used around the main figure in FIG's work. Not to say both of them were not excellent. ;) Great work guys.
I actually went ahead and deleted that lame background I had before. This is what I envisioned the drawing but I kind of did some late night work and made a poor choice by adding the texture. My friend said the same thing, he told me to detract the texture in the background and I did. I wonder if Ty Gorton of the contest will go ahead and switch the two like I asked him. Who knows.
Edited version (http://www.renderosity.com/homepage.ez?Who=FIG&ViewArticle=1629)
10-16-2002, 03:24 AM
Damn FIG, that edited version looks very nice. Me likes. Nice bit of detail in the glow from her eyes. Very cool. Guess it was there before but that white line distracted me from seeing it. Looks better this way ;cap;
Just goes to show how little changes can go a long way. The edited version (http://www.renderosity.com/homepage.ez?Who=FIG&ViewArticle=1629) is exactly how I envisioned it but I'm not sure if Ty will go ahead switch it with the current contest entry. (http://www.darkchamber.com/vm/contest1/fig.html)
The deadline was today and I made the appropriate changes before tommorrow. Hopefully he goes ahead and does it.
10-16-2002, 12:59 PM
I go with Shpydir ... Yeah.. thats pretty much it...
Too bad, I just got more votes as so now its off. BWAHAHAHAHA. My hats off to Shpydirs for taking the time to color my drawing.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.1 Copyright © 2013 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.