PSF: Jeloschi vs Wassy - Poison Ivy

[Jeloschi]

Jeloschi

http://i770.photobucket.com/albums/xx343/Jeloschi/Ivy.jpg

Wassy

http://fc02.deviantart.net/fs71/i/2012/198/8/8/poison_ivy_by_lilwassu-d57k4yq.jpg

[Chuckcamo]

this was a tough one to vote on.... good stuff from both!

[ScorpioReport]

Hmmm tough one...I must chew on this...

[D.I.S.]

both of these pieces are really good

went with Wassy 'cuz of the left buttock ;)

[Wassy]

Great work, Jeloschi! I think the thing to work on with this one (and maybe future pieces) is that she looks a bit like an amputee. I don't think her right hand (the one covered by hair) has any logical place in space, and while I assume she's in tall grass, it's not reading quite like that. It's too uniformly thick with nothing of her legs peeking out or the grass being pushed away, so again, it's like they're just chopped right off and she's flat on the ground.

The values are really nice and I think the background simple-line ivy works really well.

[amadarwin]

Ivy's face in Wassy's won me over.

[Electronick]

Wassy's Ivy has a lot more personality - voted for that.

[Popninja]

Wassy's Ivy is very sexy. The eyes helped make it super-sexy.

The composition is simple, yet great. Easy vote for me.

[Diesel]

Both very nice pieces. I went with Jeloschi because the head on Wassy's is a bit big and gives me the impression Ivy is a 13 year old girl (which, given the pose, is icky to me).