PRM: MW - Solanki vs Battlereaper - Planet Grimm

[JC Immortal]

Solanki
http://f.cl.ly/items/1B3Y1t3Y3c2L2m371J0U/295442_336897949718210_1230722307_n.jpg

Battlereaper
http://i1266.photobucket.com/albums/jj526/battlereaper21/V3-1.jpg

[Walril]

Man, this is a hard match. Both are good.

[Lord Dubu]

This one was tough for me because I like and dislike elements in both entries. In the end I went with the cleaner render.

[Electronick]

Battlereaper's is cleaner, but I gave it up to Solanki for the composition. Nicely laid out, good drama.

[C William Russette]

Both amazing pieces. I dread facing either one of you.

[ghostcat]

Gave it to Solanki for better composition

[Sedani]

These are very similar, They are both well drawn, and i like solanki's composition a little better. But BR, i like your drawing more. And it is more finished.

[Juggertha]

Wow, this was really back and forth for a bit there.

[dreno360]

While I like solanki's a ton (composition, layout, etc) Battle reapers level of completion won me over. I like his design on planet thing and the polish on the inks. There is no loser in this bout though as both artist came with the heat.

[battlereaper]

Nice work Solanki. I really like what you've done with the environment and the action of each character.


(9/1/2012) I moved stuff around on Photobucket so I have replaced the image here.
http://i1266.photobucket.com/albums/jj526/battlereaper21/Rough%20sketches/V3-1.jpg

[solanki]

Thanks Battlereaper, great job by you too. Imagine a fight where you have enough time on your hand and I have attended enough time management classes!