PDA

View Full Version : PRM: President vs Richdraws vs Juggertha (LH)



Juggertha
08-19-2010, 08:53 AM
Well now, this is the first match of the month... and a 3-way to boot.

Be kind.


The Sentry

President
http://img717.imageshack.us/img717/3798/sentryr.jpg

Richdraws
http://a.imageshack.us/img214/6071/sentryj.jpg

Juggertha
http://img408.imageshack.us/img408/4014/drawingsentryvsironman.jpg

pigeonmilk
08-19-2010, 09:00 AM
Wow what a way to start it off and EARLY even

slam
08-19-2010, 09:42 AM
Ylou got this Jugg, nice entries all around, but you can tell Jugg had the most fun doing his.

ajkarp
08-19-2010, 09:49 AM
Wow indeed! Three strong showings! President your rendering is beautiful, but your proportions are a little off. Juggertha, I like your sequentials except for the colors. Maybe a bit more saturation in places for variation. Richdraws, I have to tell you man, your image really struck me. The drama of this super being in quiet repose set against a background of such utter carnage is moving. You got my vote.

turnbolt
08-19-2010, 10:08 AM
This was hard because Juggy brought SO much to the table and I love the fire... but Rich brought the drama... SERIOUS drama... and I am in love with his cool-ass colors... President had a fun piece, but for some reason Sentry looks a bit stumpy to me... and also again... Rich's colors...

I have to say, Rich is my winner.

Telekinetic Ketchup
08-19-2010, 10:34 AM
wait... Rich's isn't supposed to be funny? I thought he was trying to say that Sentry was a treehugging superman ripoff ladyman?

richdraws
08-19-2010, 11:24 AM
wait... Rich's isn't supposed to be funny? I thought he was trying to say that Sentry was a treehugging superman ripoff ladyman?

I was sooo sorely tempted to make the image much more obvious of my contempt for the Surfs Up Superman Mincing rip off.

Popninja
08-19-2010, 11:59 AM
I know Juggertha really poured a lot into his, but there are so many things that bug me about his entry that I just can't vote for it.

President has got some major proportion issues with his entry.

richdraws, I know you did this quick. I get that. But damned if I can't stop myself for voting for it.

ajkarp
08-19-2010, 12:06 PM
Well, I'm not aware of any "Surf's Up Superman Mincing". I was reminded of the Miracleman comic where the "Black Adam" character goes apeshit all over London. The cover shows him clutching the severed head of one of his victims. John Totleben penciled and I think inked the Alan Moore script. A great comic that I totally relived after seeing Rich's drawing.

spidey976
08-20-2010, 09:25 PM
Amazing jobs one and all ... but my vote went to Juggs on this one.

Pres>This is an awesome piece but there is just something about how the figure looks a little stumped that is getting to me. There are a lot of months that this would have been a winner though.

Rich> The fact that I know this is a quick piece from you ... well it fills me with an INNER RAGE ... oppps ... sorry it was suppose to be inner ... ;). This is a awesome piece and I would love to see it completely realized, but I don't think the Sentry really looks anguished about the damaged cause. It looks like he is pouting to me ... and that is throwing me off.

Juggs> Damn fine piece m8 .. I love the story telling and the action here ... and you didn't try to give Tony a chance ... he just got his butt handed to him ... which is the way it should be.

jessemunoz
08-22-2010, 03:47 PM
I think Richdraws has the best looking piece but that pose is just bothering me. I don't really know what the Sentry is doing here. Is he molesting the pole? Is that why he is sweating? And I'm not too clear on what is in the background. Is that a building on the left? Is it falling? I love the colors. I think my vote went to Juggertha. Even though I see some things wrong I have to give it to him he went all out.

alexcat321
08-22-2010, 03:47 PM
I enjoyed juggertha's the most. He really tickles my bone with his animated colors and so forth. I really love that expression Sentry made too when he first sayd I DO! Nice one, but I think rich draws' is the most artistic so I went with his.

richdraws
08-22-2010, 07:12 PM
I think Richdraws has the best looking piece but that pose is just bothering me. I don't really know what the Sentry is doing here. Is he molesting the pole? Is that why he is sweating? And I'm not too clear on what is in the background. Is that a building on the left? Is it falling? I love the colors. I think my vote went to Juggertha. Even though I see some things wrong I have to give it to him he went all out.

Sentry was originally buggering superman whilst metropolis burned in the background. But the auto censor feature on penciljack altered the image upon posting. Sorry x

hadesillustrations
08-22-2010, 09:40 PM
Sentry was originally buggering superman whilst metropolis burned in the background. But the auto censor feature on penciljack altered the image upon posting. Sorry x

Hooooooootttttttttt. Can you email that to me. I need it for...research...or something.

Well done all of you. Richdraws' had tons of emotion in his piece - it really showed Sentry's mental instability. And I like the falling buildings - subtle and poignant. Excellent.

NickRocks
08-22-2010, 10:55 PM
i kept coming back to richdraws